Holiday bonus payroll is simple once you accept the first rule: a bonus is taxable wages and it runs through payroll like any other paycheck. That means a $500 bonus lands in an employee’s account at roughly $350 after flat federal withholding and Social Security and Medicare, before state tax, and if you want them to actually receive $500, you gross it up to somewhere around $710. We run an accounting firm that does payroll in-house, and the bonus run is the one payroll every year where the owner’s intent and the employee’s deposit don’t match, because nobody said which number they meant.
Here are the rules, in the order the questions come up.
Before you promise anyone anything, decide whether “$500” means the gross amount on the pay stub or the net amount in their hand.
If it’s gross, the employee sees about $350 and may feel shortchanged. If it’s net, you gross it up: pay enough that after withholding and payroll taxes the deposit is $500, which means the gross is roughly $710 and your cost, with employer payroll tax on top, is higher still. Neither is wrong. Both are fine to do. What goes badly is promising $500, running it as gross, and having the conversation on December 23.
Decide it in November, tell your payroll provider which one you mean, and write the total cost of the run, including employer tax, on the cash forecast for the week it pays.
Yes. A bonus is supplemental wages. It’s subject to federal and state income tax withholding, Social Security and Medicare, and unemployment taxes, and it shows up on the W-2 like everything else. There’s no exception for holiday bonuses, “gifts,” or amounts under some threshold. Cash handed across the bar in an envelope is still wages, and it’s still your obligation to report and withhold on it.
Paying a bonus outside payroll, by personal check or cash, doesn’t make it not wages. It makes it unreported wages, which is a problem for both of you.
For supplemental wages paid separately from regular pay, most employers use the flat federal rate of 22%. On top of that comes the employee’s share of Social Security and Medicare at 7.65%, and state withholding if your state has income tax. So the federal-plus-FICA take on a $500 bonus is about $148, leaving roughly $352 before state. That’s where the “$500 becomes $350” math comes from.
The alternative is the aggregate method: add the bonus to a regular paycheck and withhold on the total using the employee’s normal W-4. For lower-paid employees, aggregate withholding can be less than 22%; for higher-paid ones it can be more. Either method is allowed. Either way, withholding is a prepayment; the employee’s actual tax on the bonus is settled on their return in April. The flat 22% is just the most predictable, which is why most bonus runs use it.
Yes, at face value. A $100 gift card is $100 of wages, and it goes through payroll with withholding, usually on the next regular check.
The confusion comes from the de minimis fringe rule, which lets you give small, infrequent, hard-to-value things, a holiday ham, a company jacket, flowers, without running them through payroll. Cash and cash equivalents are specifically excluded from that rule, no matter how small. A gift card is a cash equivalent. So is a Visa card, a prepaid card, or a check. If it has a dollar value printed on it, it’s wages.
If you want to give something that isn’t taxable, give a thing, not a card.
When the bonus is paid decides which year it’s deducted in and which year’s W-2 it lands on. For a cash-basis business, a bonus paid December 31 is a 2026 deduction; the same bonus paid January 2 is a 2027 deduction and 2027 wages to the employee. Accrual-basis employers have some room to deduct a year-end bonus paid early the next year, with limits for owners and their relatives, but for most small businesses the rule of thumb holds: paid in December, deducted in December.
Which year you want it in depends on the tax estimate. In a strong 2026, the December deduction is worth more. In a thin 2026 with a stronger 2027 expected, January can be the better year. That’s a question for the estimate, not for the calendar.
The bonus run usually lands in the same two weeks as the last regular payroll of the year, the slowest customer payments of the year, and rent on January 1, with the January 15 estimate right behind. Add employer payroll tax on top of the gross, and a bonus run that “feels like” $10,000 can be $12,000 or more leaving the account in one day.
Put the real number on the forecast for the real date. If the week doesn’t clear, the answer is to change the date or the amount in November, not to bounce a payroll in December.
A fractional CFO puts the bonus run on the 13-week cash forecast in October, grossed up or not, with employer tax included, on the actual pay date. Then two things happen. The forecast shows whether the week clears, and if it doesn’t, there’s still time to move the run to the first payroll of January or trim the pool. And the tax estimate shows which year the deduction is worth more in, so the date is chosen on purpose. The bonus becomes a planned line instead of a December surprise, and the owner knows the total cost before promising anyone a number.
We run payroll and close the books for the same clients, so the bonus run ties to the books the day it pays, the gross-up is decided in advance, and gift cards get picked up on the next check instead of being found in April. If you’re paying bonuses this year and haven’t decided gross or net, or the run isn’t on a cash forecast yet, reach out. It’s a fifteen-minute conversation in November and a headache in December.
Are holiday bonuses taxable?
Yes; they’re wages, subject to withholding and payroll tax, and must run through payroll.
How much is withheld from a bonus?
Typically a flat 22% federal plus 7.65% for Social Security and Medicare, then state, so a $500 bonus is roughly $350 in hand before state tax.
Are gift cards taxable?
Yes, at face value; cash equivalents don’t qualify for the de minimis exception.
Restaurant tips are wages, a mandatory service charge is revenue, tip credit is state-specific, and…
Buy vs. lease equipment for a small business: cash first, then tax, then five-year cost,…
Holiday cash flow for small business: nobody pays between December 15 and January 5. Bill…
Two things before December 31 that change the return: a year-end inventory count that sets…
Our monthly bookkeeping calendar for every client: statements by day 3, reconciliations by day 8,…
A contractor WIP schedule at year end decides the tax bill: overbilled jobs are liabilities,…