Buy vs. Lease Equipment for a Small Business: How to Decide
The buy vs. lease decision for small-business equipment has four questions, and the order matters: cash first, tax second, total five-year cost third, and how you’ll use the equipment fourth. Most owners start with the fourth, and the salesperson starts with the second. We run an accounting firm, and the December version of this decision, when a dealer is pushing a year-end deal and the owner is thinking about a tax bill, is where the order gets scrambled most often.
Here’s each question, in the order we work them for clients, and what each one actually decides.
Cash: does the down payment land in the worst week?
Before tax, before the five-year math, before anything, the question is whether you can pay for it without hurting the business in the weeks right after.
Buying usually means a down payment now, whether you’re paying cash or financing. Leasing usually means a first payment and a deposit, and a smaller number in the first month. Pull up the 13-week cash forecast and put the down payment in the week it would actually leave the account. If that week is already the low point of the quarter, which in December it usually is, then the buy option has a cost that no tax deduction offsets: the risk of missing payroll or the January 15 estimate.
If cash says no to buying, the decision is made, and the rest of this article is about next year. If cash says yes, keep going.
Is it better to buy or lease equipment for tax purposes?
It depends on what kind of year you’re having, and that’s the part the dealer doesn’t know.
When you buy, and the equipment is delivered and ready to use by December 31, you can generally deduct the full cost this year through Section 179 or 100% bonus depreciation, which applies to property acquired after January 19, 2025. Financed or not, the whole price is deductible in year one if it qualifies. When you lease, you deduct the lease payments as you make them, so the deduction is spread across the term.
In a strong year, the big year-one deduction is worth a lot: it comes off income taxed at your highest rate. In a thin year, it’s worth much less, and Section 179 in particular can’t take you below zero business income. A lease’s steady deduction may fit a thin year better, and the cash spread matters more.
Two cautions. First, a lease that’s really a financing arrangement, with a token buyout at the end, is treated as a purchase for tax no matter what the contract calls it. Second, a deduction is a discount, not a refund. In a 30% bracket, a $60,000 purchase saves about $18,000 in tax and costs $42,000 of real money.
Real cost: the five-year comparison
Put both options on one page over five years.
Buy: purchase price, plus interest if financed, plus maintenance once the warranty ends, minus what you can sell it for at year five.
Lease: every payment over the term, plus the deposit, plus any end-of-term charges (mileage, wear, return fees), plus the buyout if you’d keep it, plus the maintenance the lease doesn’t cover.
Then add the tax effect to each side: the year-one deduction for buying, the annual payment deductions for leasing, both at your actual rate.
When we run this for clients, the five-year totals are usually closer than the salesperson implied. Leasing rarely “saves money” in total; it moves the money around. What it buys is a lower payment now, and the ability to hand the thing back. What buying gets you is the asset at the end and, in a good year, a big deduction up front.
Use: run it into the ground or replace it in three years?
This is the question owners want to start with, and it’s a real one; it’s just the last one.
If it’s a truck you’ll drive for ten years, a piece of shop equipment that doesn’t go out of date, or anything you’ll modify or use hard, buy it. Leases penalize wear and mileage, and you’ll want to own something you’re going to keep past the lease term anyway.
If it’s technology that’s obsolete in three years, a vehicle you’ll rack miles on but want to swap regularly, or something you’re trying for the first time and may not need, leasing keeps the exit open.
Use tells you which option fits the business. Cash tells you whether you can afford it now. Tax tells you what it’s worth this year. The five-year cost tells you the real price. Answered in that order, the decision is usually obvious.
Does leasing equipment save money?
Over the full term, usually not, once you count the deposit, end-of-term charges, and the buyout. What it saves is cash in the early months, and that can be worth paying for if the early months are tight. The mistake is treating a lower monthly payment as a lower price. It’s a longer one.
What a CFO does with this number
A fractional CFO answers all four questions in one quarterly report, so the decision is made from numbers instead of from a brochure. The cash forecast shows the down payment in the week it lands. The tax estimate, built from closed books, shows the bracket and whether Section 179 has room this year. The five-year comparison is a one-page table. The use question comes from a five-minute conversation about how long you’ll keep it.
Then the CFO says it plainly: buy it, take delivery by December 31, and here’s the payment on the forecast; or lease it starting in January because the deduction isn’t worth much this year and cash is thin; or wait, because the equipment isn’t needed yet and the dealer’s deadline isn’t your deadline.
Where we come in
The buy vs. lease call is part of our advisory tier, and it runs off the same closed books we produce every month. If you’re facing a December equipment decision and the only analysis so far has come from the person selling it, reach out. We’ll work the four questions in order and give you a recommendation you can act on before the year ends.
Frequently asked questions
Buy or lease for taxes?
In a big year, buying and placing in service by December 31 gives a large deduction now; in a thin year the deduction is worth less and leasing’s cash spread matters more.
What comes first in the decision?
Cash: whether the down payment lands in the low week of the forecast, before tax is even considered.
Does leasing save money?
Over five years the totals are usually closer than the salesperson implies; the difference is timing and use.